Judith Butler‘s complicated brain in prose. A conversation piece.
209 pages, ★★
I love women, but even I see Judith Butler’s brain as a incomprehensibly tangled mess.
As someone who persistently tried—and failed—to ‘fit in’, Judith Butler wrote Gender Trouble in an attempt to understand her own identity. She didn’t feel fully-accepted into any socially-constructed identity, so in Gender Trouble, she carved out her own.
I care less about what she writes than about why she writes it. Contemplating the differences between men and women on a philosophical level is pointless for most of us, but it would be of great inspiration to someone in similar shoes to the author. Actually, the author said in an interview, “Gender Trouble was an attempt to understand how my family and myself failed to comply with Hollywood norms”. Voilà.
“Gender Trouble was an attempt to understand how my family and myself failed to comply with Hollywood norms” — Judith Butler
My first impression was “this book is unintelligible”. I had a dictionary at hand for words like phantasma, cathexis, exogamy and phallogocentrism but not all of them were there. After 80 pages, I retreated to YouTube and Wikipedia in search of summaries and author interviews. I side-tracked onto Slavoj Žižek videos before going back to the book. Most of it still looks unintelligible to me.
Despite not really understanding this book, Gender Trouble made an excellent conversation piece. This book stimulated hours of discussion in my living room (even though nobody fully understood this book); we talked about sex, lesbians, equality, sexual identity, and most interestingly, why some people feel compelled to write books about it all.
One reading is clearly not enough. I missed 100% of the humour and 99% of the point. Maybe that’s because I’m a man. Or maybe it’s because I’m just stupid. I promise to read it again.
I prefer Slavoj Žižek as a philosopher. ★★
- The Phallus Fallacy (onemindmanydetours.wordpress.com)
- Captive Genders Reading @ Elliott Bay Book Company (revolutionbythebook.akpress.org)
- Reblog: Schools of Literary Criticism: Feminism/Gender Studies (harmonioushandbook.com)
- 2.en.30 The gender gap: gender versus sex. (1esoe1011.wordpress.com)