Tragic period of Chinese history made funny by terrible English and production.
191 pages, ★★
An Introduction to Modern China History is riddled with errors, some of which are funny. Fonts and text colours change haphazardly, which indicates careless copy-and-paste jobs from external sources. Fixed-width symbols are used instead of Roman numerals, and the book suffers greatly from bad grammar, repetition and missing punctuation throughout. Historical references are sometimes questionable, too: answers.com and blogspot.com are each cited several times. I would have a field day proofreading this book.
Grave historical mistakes are also made. Confucius most certainly did not “invent” Confucianism, and the Taiping Rebellion did not occur in 1950.
The intended audience is explained in the book’s opening sentence: “Generally speaking, this book is provided to the overseas students who study in Jinan University.” The majority of overseas students in Jinan University probably won’t even open this book.
The second sentence is utter nonsense: “As a book of history, the basic historic events should be the most important material of the book”. Delete.
As a proofreader, terrible English prevented me from taking this book seriously. I learned little. Read Stilwell and the American Experience in China, 1911-45 instead. ★★
- Book: Quick Access to Chinese History: From Ancient Times to the 21st Century (jameskennedymonash.wordpress.com)
- Opinion: Is China Ripe for a Revolution? (nytimes.com)
- “The dark side of China’s economic rise has been a shocking widening of the gulf between the…” (underpaidgenius.com)
1 thought on “Book: An Introduction to Modern China History (1840–1949)”